Auctions for Government Securities: A Laboratory Comparison of Uniform, Discriminatory and Spanish Designs
نویسندگان
چکیده
The Bank of Spain uses a unique auction format to sell government bonds, which can be seen as a hybrid of a uniform and a discriminatory auction. For winning bids above the average winning bid, buyers are charged the average winning bid, otherwise they pay their respective bids. We report on an experiment that compares this auction format to the discriminatory format, used in most other countries, and to the uniform format. Our design is based on a common value model with multi-unit supply and two-unit demand. The results show significantly higher revenue with the Spanish and the uniform formats than with the discriminatory one, while volatility of prices over time is significantly lower in the discriminatory format than in the Spanish and uniform cases. Actual price dispersion is significantly larger in the discriminatory than in the Spanish. Our data also exhibit the use of bid-spreading strategies in all three designs.
منابع مشابه
Bidding Behavior in Multi-Unit Auctions — An Experimental Investigation and some Theoretical Insights¤
We present laboratory experiments of ...ve di¤erent multi-unit auction mechanisms. Two units of a homogeneous object were auctioned o¤ among two bidders with ‡at demand for two units. We test whether expected demand reduction occurs in open and sealed–bid uniform–price auctions. Revenue equivalence is tested for these auctions as well as for the Ausubel, the Vickrey and the discriminatory seale...
متن کاملBidding Behavior in Multi-Unit Auctions
We present laboratory experiments of five different multi-unit auction mechanisms. Two units of a homogeneous object were auctioned off among two bidders with flat demand for two units. We test whether expected demand reduction occurs in open and sealed–bid uniform–price auctions. Revenue equivalence is tested for these auctions as well as for the Ausubel, the Vickrey and the discriminatory sea...
متن کاملDesigning multi-unit multiple bid auctions: An agent-based computational model of uniform, discriminatory and generalized Vickrey auctions
Multi-unit auctions are being employed by public agencies to allocate resources and to purchase services. These auctions resolve the lumpy bid problem inherent in single-unit auctions by allowing bidders to submit a supply or demand schedule. However, the choice of pricing formats for multi-unit auctions is controversial. Neither economic theory nor laboratory experiments depict a complete pict...
متن کاملPrice Discovery in Emissions Permit Auctions
Auctions are increasingly being used to allocate emissions allowances (“permits”) for cap and trade and common-pool resource management programs. These auctions create thick markets that can provide important information about changes in current market conditions. This paper reports a laboratory experiment in which half of the bidders experienced unannounced increases in their willingness to pa...
متن کاملAnalysis of Uniform and Discriminatory Price Auctions in Restructured Electricity Markets*
The settlement rule used to determine payments in electricity market auctions can have a profound impact on the amount paid for a particular service. This paper evaluates two auction settlement rules: the uniform price auction in which the last offer accepted determines the price paid to all participants and the discriminatory price auction in which each participant is paid the amount bid by th...
متن کامل